Disagreeing with an insurance company’s determination of fault after a car accident can feel frustrating and unfair. In Las Vegas, where busy roads and complex traffic laws create frequent disputes, challenging an incorrect decision is essential to protecting your compensation.
Nevada’s comparative negligence laws allow you to recover damages even if you share some fault, but the process requires clear evidence and a strategic approach. Jack Bernstein Injury Lawyers has the expertise to guide you through these disputes, ensuring your rights are upheld and your claim is fairly resolved.
How Insurance Companies Determine Fault in Car Accidents
Insurance companies use a combination of evidence, policies, and sometimes assumptions to determine fault in car accidents. While their decision plays a major role in processing claims, it’s important to remember that their findings are not the final say and can be challenged.
The Typical Process Insurers Follow
Fault determinations rely on evidence gathered from various sources. Insurance adjusters use this information to piece together what happened:
- Police Reports:
- These are often the starting point for fault determinations. Police reports include officer observations, citations, and an initial analysis of who may be at fault.
- Photos and Videos:
- Adjusters review images from the accident scene, vehicle damage, and any available dashcam or traffic camera footage to reconstruct the events.
- Witness Statements:
- Eyewitnesses can provide unbiased accounts that clarify the sequence of events.
- Driver Accounts:
- Insurers will also consider statements from the drivers involved. However, inconsistencies in these accounts can lead to disputes.
The insurer’s goal is to protect their financial interests, so their fault determination may not always align with the facts.
Common Errors in Fault Determinations
Even when adjusters follow standard procedures, mistakes can happen. Some common errors include:
- Overlooking Evidence
- Misinterpreting Traffic Laws
- Relying on Biased Information
Example: At a busy Las Vegas intersection, a driver may be cited for failing to yield, but evidence like traffic camera footage could reveal that the other driver ran a red light. Errors like these can significantly impact the outcome of your claim.
Role of Nevada’s Comparative Negligence Laws
Nevada follows a comparative negligence rule, which means multiple parties can share fault for an accident. This rule impacts compensation:
- Recovering Damages:
- As long as you are less than 50% at fault, you can still recover damages, though your compensation will be reduced by your percentage of fault.
- Importance of Disputes:
- Challenging an insurer’s determination can reduce your fault percentage, potentially increasing your final settlement.
By understanding how insurers determine fault and identifying potential errors, you can challenge their conclusions effectively and work toward a fair outcome.
Steps to Dispute an Insurance Company’s Fault Decision
If you believe an insurance company’s determination of fault is incorrect, taking immediate and strategic action is essential. A successful dispute relies on gathering strong evidence, presenting your case clearly, and escalating your concerns when necessary.
Collecting Evidence to Support Your Claim
Evidence is the foundation of any successful fault dispute. The stronger your proof, the harder it becomes for the insurer to deny your claim.
Key Evidence to Gather:
- Photos and Videos:
- Capture the accident scene, vehicle damage, and road conditions. Even small details, like skid marks or debris patterns, can support your case.
- Police Reports:
- Obtain a copy of the police report. If it contains errors or omissions, work with your attorney to correct them promptly.
- Witness Statements:
- Reach out to eyewitnesses for detailed accounts of the accident. Written or recorded statements can be particularly compelling.
- Medical Records:
- Document all injuries related to the accident. These records can demonstrate the severity of the crash and counter any claims that you exaggerated your injuries.
Traffic camera footage from Las Vegas intersections can provide objective proof of what happened. Request this footage as soon as possible, as it is often only stored for a short time.
Writing a Strong Dispute Letter
A clear, well-documented dispute letter can compel the insurer to revisit their decision. Focus on facts and professionalism.
Tips for Writing Your Letter:
- Start with a Summary:
- Briefly explain why you are disputing the determination and highlight the key evidence supporting your claim.
- Include Supporting Evidence:
- Attach relevant documents, such as photos, witness statements, and police reports.
- Cite Relevant Laws:
- Reference Nevada traffic laws or comparative negligence rules if they apply to your case.
- Be Respectful but Firm:
- Avoid emotional language. Stick to facts and a professional tone.
Example Statement: “Based on the attached dashcam footage, it is clear that I had the right of way at the intersection, and the other driver failed to yield. I respectfully request a review of the fault determination in light of this evidence.”
Escalating the Dispute If Necessary
If the insurer denies your initial dispute, don’t give up. You have options to escalate the issue and seek further review.
Steps to Escalate:
- Contact a Supervisor:
- Request that a higher-level adjuster review your case. Sometimes, escalating internally resolves disputes.
- File a Complaint with Nevada’s Division of Insurance:
- If you believe the insurer is acting unfairly or ignoring evidence, file a formal complaint. The Division of Insurance can investigate and mediate disputes.
- Explore Mediation or Arbitration:
- Mediation involves a neutral third party helping both sides reach an agreement, while arbitration is a more formal process that can result in a binding decision.
How Nevada’s Comparative Negligence Impacts Fault Disputes
Nevada’s comparative negligence law plays a critical role in fault disputes, as it determines how compensation is calculated when multiple parties share responsibility for an accident.
Adjusting Fault Percentages in Disputes
Disputing a fault determination can reduce your assigned percentage of fault, which directly impacts your compensation. Strong evidence and legal support can significantly influence how fault is reassigned.
| Fault Percentage | Impact on Settlement |
|---|---|
| 10% | Settlement reduced by 10%. |
| 30% | Settlement reduced by 30%. |
| Over 50% | No compensation awarded. |
Example:
If your claim is worth $15,000 but you’re assigned 30% of the fault, your compensation will be reduced to $10,500. However, if you successfully dispute and lower your fault to 10%, your settlement increases to $13,500.
Why Fault Adjustments Matter
Reducing your fault percentage can mean the difference between recovering damages and walking away with nothing. Additionally, insurers may be more likely to settle fairly when strong evidence disputes their initial determination.
When and Why to Consult a Lawyer for Fault Disputes
Challenging an insurance company’s fault determination can be a complex and frustrating process. While you can handle some disputes on your own, there are situations where having a skilled lawyer is essential to protecting your rights and securing a fair outcome.
Protecting Your Rights During the Dispute
Insurance companies have teams of adjusters and attorneys working to minimize their liability. A lawyer can level the playing field by ensuring that your interests are represented.
- Ensuring Fair Treatment:
- Your lawyer will hold the insurer accountable to Nevada laws and prevent them from unfairly shifting blame.
- Correcting Faulty Determinations:
- Attorneys are adept at presenting evidence in a compelling way to counter biased or incomplete conclusions.
- Minimizing Fault Assignment:
- If you are partially at fault, a lawyer can argue to reduce your percentage of responsibility, maximizing your compensation.
A lawyer’s involvement signals to the insurer that you are serious about challenging their determination, often leading to faster and fairer resolutions.
Pursuing Legal Action if Necessary
If a fault dispute cannot be resolved through negotiations or mediation, you may need to consider filing a lawsuit. Legal representation is critical at this stage.
- Building a Strong Case:
- A lawyer can subpoena additional evidence, such as traffic camera footage or black box data, and bring in expert witnesses like accident reconstruction specialists.
- Navigating Nevada’s Legal System:
- Fault disputes can escalate into court proceedings, where legal expertise ensures you meet procedural requirements and argue effectively.
- Maximizing Compensation:
- In cases of disputed liability, an attorney can fight for the highest possible compensation, taking into account all damages, including medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering.
Many fault disputes are resolved without going to court, but having a lawyer ready to take legal action strengthens your negotiating position.
Take Action to Resolve Your Fault Dispute
Disputing an insurance company’s fault determination is a critical step in protecting your rights and ensuring fair compensation. By understanding how fault is determined, gathering strong evidence, and escalating disputes when necessary, you can challenge incorrect decisions effectively. Nevada’s comparative negligence laws make it especially important to minimize your fault percentage to maximize your compensation.
If disputes stall or evidence is contested, consulting an experienced lawyer can make all the difference. Jack Bernstein Injury Lawyers has the expertise to navigate these disputes, ensuring you receive the fair treatment and compensation you deserve.
Our Location
Contact Us for a Free Consultation
If you have been injured in an accident, contact Jack Bernstein Injury Lawyers for a free, no obligation consultation with experienced Las Vegas accident lawyers. You will gain an advocate for every stage in the claims process until you have the compensation you deserve.
Jack Bernstein Injury Lawyers is available to help you handle your injury claim in the Las Vegas metropolitan area and beyond. Jack Bernstein and his team can offer you the personalized service and legal representation you deserve after an accident.
Call us at (702) 633-3333 or contact us today for a free consultation to discuss your case.
